In the State of Israel: Guilty Before Found Guilty

In the State of Israel there is no freedom of religion and Jews are guilty before found guilty.

In my recent visit to Jerusalem, while sightseeing in the city I decided it would be worth my while to also pay a visit to Temple Mount. I was told that it could be a challenge as the line of people who wish to go up and visit is long and the time frame to do so is short.

I stood in line already at 7:00am and checking in started at 7:30am. In no time I found myself standing in front of the security personnel.

Jerusalem - Temple Mount entry sign. Photo by Nurit Greenger
Jerusalem – Temple Mount entry sign. Photo by Nurit Greenger

The security man I faced first asked me if I was alone or with a group. I told him I was alone.

Then he continued and asked me if I was Jewish and if I was religious; I told him I was Jewish.

He then looked at me and saw I was wearing a Star of David necklace and he told me the Star of David was too large. He left his position to ask his boss his opinion and the boss approved my necklace.

The man then went on to check my bag and found in it a small Jewish prayer book called Sidur, which I carry with me in my bag, as a good luck charm, on any trip I take. The man, with a smirk on his face, this time called his boss complaining I have a prayer book and that man shouted at me, no prayer books, no prayer up there.

I told him I was not going to pray and asked him to keep the book for me till I get back from the visit and his answer was, “throw it away.”

Guilty Before Found Guilty

I was denied entry and was told, “come back tomorrow.”

Jerusalem - guilty before found guilty, Temple Mount line to go up. Photo by Nurit Greenger
Jerusalem-Temple Mount line to go up. Photo by Nurit Greenger

I was found guilty of misbehaving before I was guilty of misbehaving while visiting Temple Mount. And who is dictating the parameters of this misbehavior?

My question to the Israeli authorities is: are Moslems allowed to have prayer books when they are praying at their mosque on Temple Mount?

Since I was already in the sacred area I walked down to the Western Wall section to calm down and pray.

Crazy Man

While I spent a few long minutes at the Wall praying and chatting with some fellow praying women, a Moslem man standing on the bridge that takes you to Temple Mount, located just above the woman section where I stood, went berserk.

He repetitiously shouted, in the loudest of voice, some words among them “allahu akbar,” totally disturbing and disrespecting the Jewish women praying beneath.

It took the authorities a long a while to get this madcap to stop his yelling.

Questions For Israel

My question to the Israeli authorities is: who is dictating the freedom of religion on Temple Mount? Is it the tolerant Israel or the intolerant, fascistically uncompromising Moslems?

My question to the Israeli authorities is: are you a democracy that offers tolerance by all to all or only by some to some?

I could try go back, less my good-luck charm prayer book, and stand in line again to go up to Temple Mount. But as the woman who works at the women section at the Wall told me: “God loves you and He guided you so you do not go up there, rather stay by the Wall and pray.”

Perhaps it is better for me not to have been a witness to the disrespect the Moslems have toward the Holiest to Jews?

Temple Mount is the Holiest to Jews, not the Moslems. It is a disgrace that the government of Israel allows such conduct to take place there while continuously declaring it is the “only democracy in the Middle East.” My question to the Israeli authorities is: is what you govern by a new type invented democracy or it is democratatorship?

Poor Excuse For Bad Behavior

I was told that the day I tried visiting Temple Mount was the first day of the last ten days of the Moslem holiday Ramadan, a month of fasting to commemorate the first revelation of the Quran to Muhammad according to Islamic belief.

During these ten days it has been “customary” for Moslems to camp and sleep on Temple Mount and cause a ruckus. To avoid clashes, for years, the Israeli authorities forbade visitors to go up to Temple Mount during those ten days.

This year, no matter, Temple Mount was open to visitors during the permitted hours during Ramadan, even the last days of this Moslem holiday. Is this a small milestone to advance Moslem tolerance in Israel, so badly needed worldwide?

In Israel there is no freedom of religion to Jews only to all other religions. When it comes to Moslems in Israel it is their “right” to freedom of religion and no one else’s.

Since 1967, one government of Israel after another had ample opportunities to, step by step, correct this wrong and make it right. Demand and teach Moslem tolerance to all other religions. Yet, it chose not to act in that direction.

The result is that I, a Jew, cannot freely go visit the place where the two Temples that housed the tabernacle, built by my ancestors, once stood.

How shameful that Jews are guilty before found guilty in Jerusalem.

Nurit Greenger
During the 2006 second Lebanon War, Nurit Greenger, referenced then as the "Accidental Reporter" felt compelled to become an activist. Being an 'out-of-the-box thinker, Nurit is a passionately committed advocate for Jews, Israel, the United States, and the Free World in general. From Southern California, Nurit serves as a "one-woman Hasbarah army" for Israel who believes that if you stand for nothing, you will fall for anything.

Email Notification

Get notification of new stories by Nurit Greenger, in your Email.