Third Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals Sets a New Standard for Workplace Harassment

Is a single racial slur in the workplace enough to establish harassment?

It is common knowledge that in the United States our civil rights are protected by law and that it is illegal to harass anyone in the workplace on the basis of race, religion, ethnicity, gender or sexual orientation. During the past two decades, however, the precedents about what constitutes workplace discrimination have been confusing and even contradictory. As of July 14, 2017, the Third Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals ruled that a single racial slur in the workplace can be sufficient cause to file a harassment lawsuit. The three judges on the panel declared that discriminatory speech or behavior need not be both “severe and pervasive” to be considered harassment, but rather that it may be either “severe or pervasive.” This may seem like a minor distinction, but in fact it is a significant one.

A Reversal of an Earlier Ruling

The Third Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals clarified the basis for discrimination lawsuits by deciding that a particularly egregious single spoken word or action is enough to create a hostile work environment. The court’s ruling reversed an earlier judgment from the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania. The District Court’s decision in the case of Castleberry v. STI Group had dismissed all claims against the company. Apparently, the lower court felt that a single incident of discriminatory speech or action could not be assessed as establishing a hostile work environment.

The Case in Point

The case revolved around the following situation: Two African men, Atron Castleberry and John Brown, general laborers on a pipeline project for Chesapeake Energy Corp. were fired from their jobs as a direct result of reporting onsite verbal abuse to their supervisors. The verbal abuse they complained of was, without a doubt, foul and discriminatory. Both men reported that they had been told they would be terminated if they “nigger-rigged” a fence that they were tasked with removing. At the time, Castleberry and Brown were both working for STI Group, the staffing agency and subcontractor for the project. They filed a lawsuit against STI for racial discrimination.

Early on, the attorneys for STI tried to block the case with the argument that no courts had previously affirmed a ruling in which one isolated incident could be determined to constitute a hostile work environment. Judge Thomas Ambro, however, pointed out that the defendant’s argument missed the essence of the protection afforded by the The Supreme Court’s decision to adopt the phrase “severe or pervasive” statement. In other words, the law clearly spells out, by using the word “or,” that a single incident of discriminatory abuse may be, if severe enough, sufficient to determine a plaintiff’s harassment claim.

Untangling Justice

In his decision, Judge Ambro cited cases going back to 2001 in which varying standards had been used to determine culpability in discrimination cases. Not only had some courts used the “severe or pervasive” standard, but at least one had used a standard of “pervasive and regular.” In the end, Judge Ambro decided that the ultimate standard by which such cases should be determined is the one laid out by the U.S. Supreme Court as early as 1993: “severe or pervasive.”

Judge Ambro also pointed out that we should not be led astray by past inconsistencies when interpreting this case. Because the supervisor’s use of a racial slur was accompanied by a threat of termination, and because that termination actually occurred, there is no question that this workplace was a hostile, racially charged environment.

Hot this week

Did David Wineland and Serge Haroche Steal Idea For The Nobel Physics Prize?

Dr. Omerbashich says the Royal Swedish Academy is a Crime Scene and he has the proof that Nobel laureates stole his discovery.

New Approaches to Disaster Relief Challenges

Disaster relief has always been a challenge. NASA, Google,...

3 Legitimate Money Making Methods to Supplement Your Income

In a perfect world, when your landlord raises your...

2016 Predictions by World Renowned Medium and Psychic Lindy Baker

World renowned medium and psychic Lindy Baker is interviewed by The Hollywood Sentinel, discussing psychic power, the spirit world, life after death, areas of concern in 2016, and much more.

Digital Coupon Customers Spending More Than Double At Stores

A new study shows that customers who use digital coupons go shopping more for groceries and other household goods more often and spend more on their shopping trips.

The Checkup Men Skip: What Testicular and Prostate Warning Signs Actually Look Like

Men are remarkably good at tolerating discomfort and remarkably bad at reporting it. Ask a urologist what the most common delay in genitourinary cancer care looks like, and the answer is rarely a diagnostic failure. It is a man who noticed

The Research Report Passed Review, but the Evidence Was Incomplete: Why Biotechnology Companies Need Stronger Scientific Audit Trails

A biotechnology company receives a laboratory report that appears to confirm a research finding. The figures are consistent, the document has been reviewed, and the reported result seems sufficient to support the next stage of an investigat

What to Expect at Your First Pointe Shoe Fitting

For all young dancers who take even a single...

The Insurer’s Nurse Followed You Into the Exam Room

You're on the paper-covered exam table waiting for the orthopedist when someone you've never met walks in behind the nurse. She introduces herself as the case manager assigned to your workers' compensation claim, takes the chair by the door

When the Second Assist Vanishes, Who Carries the Exposure?

A lumbar fusion requires more than the surgeon's hands. Retractors must maintain exposure, instruments need to move efficiently, and the team must respond when bleeding or difficult anatomy changes the operative plan. In some operating room

I Tested Stop Brain Clutter App’s Personalized Meditation System

Stop Brain Clutter takes a different approach to guided meditation. The app builds a personalized meditation from information you give it.

Israel, You Must Muster Unity

But what makes Israel particularly remarkable is the idea that unity does not require sameness.

Related Articles

Popular Categories