California Union ‘Between a Man and a Woman’ is Unconstitutional

The California Supreme Court today overturned the earlier ban on the recognition of gay union as “marriage.”

The bench was made up of Chief Justice Ronald M. George, Associate Justice Carlos R. Moreno, Associate Justice Joyce L. Kennard, Associate Justice Kathryn Mickle Werdegar, Associate Justice Ming W. Chin, Associate Justice Marvin R. Baxter, and Associate Justice Carol A. Corrigan.

In California, the union of a man and a woman can be called “marriage,” with a same-sex union called “domestic partnership.” According to the court, “The question we must address is whether, under these circumstances, the failure to designate the official relationship of same-sex couples as marriage violates the California Constitution.”

All rise for the California Supreme Court, in the 2008 Marriage Rules case
All rise for the California Supreme Court, in the 2008 Marriage Rules case

Chief Justice George wrote the majority opinion, with Justices Kennard, Werdegar and Moreno concurring. Justice Kennard wrote a separate concurring opinion, to explain “how the decision is consistent with Lockyer v. City and County of San Francisco (2004) 33 Cal.4th 1055 (Lockyer), to note Lockyer’s effect on marriages of same-sex couples previously performed in California.” Justices Baxter and Corrigan wrote separate dissenting opinions, with Justice Chin concurring with Justice Baxter.

The Majority Opinion states:

Accordingly, in light of the conclusions we reach concerning the constitutional questions brought to us for resolution, we determine that the language of section 300 limiting the designation of marriage to a union “between a man and a woman” is unconstitutional and must be stricken from the statute, and that the remaining statutory language must be understood as making the designation of marriage available both to opposite-sex and same-sex couples. In addition, because the limitation of marriage to opposite-sex couples imposed by section 308.5 can have no constitutionally permissible effect in light of the constitutional conclusions set forth in this opinion, that provision cannot stand.” [ PDF ]

The court said a “writ of mandate” will direct California state officials to effect the ruling, so local authorities can comply with it. If not further extended by the court, the decision takes effect in 30 days.

In what appears to be a strange comment in the majority opinon, the Chief Justice says:

“In the present case, it is readily apparent that extending the designation of marriage to same-sex couples clearly is more consistent with the probable legislative intent than withholding that designation from both opposite-sex couples and same-sex couples in favor of some other, uniform designation.”

It appears the justices made an opinion based on an unclear part of law because they are not really sure what the legislature really meant. ( “probable legislative intent” }

Hot this week

Did David Wineland and Serge Haroche Steal Idea For The Nobel Physics Prize?

Dr. Omerbashich says the Royal Swedish Academy is a Crime Scene and he has the proof that Nobel laureates stole his discovery.

New Approaches to Disaster Relief Challenges

Disaster relief has always been a challenge. NASA, Google,...

3 Legitimate Money Making Methods to Supplement Your Income

In a perfect world, when your landlord raises your...

2016 Predictions by World Renowned Medium and Psychic Lindy Baker

World renowned medium and psychic Lindy Baker is interviewed by The Hollywood Sentinel, discussing psychic power, the spirit world, life after death, areas of concern in 2016, and much more.

Digital Coupon Customers Spending More Than Double At Stores

A new study shows that customers who use digital coupons go shopping more for groceries and other household goods more often and spend more on their shopping trips.

The Research Document That Changed Meaning in Translation: Why Bilingual Scientific Suppliers Need One Verifiable Record Across Languages

A scientific document can remain visually identical while its meaning changes significantly in translation. A laboratory report may contain the same tables, analytical figures, dates and identifiers in two languages, yet a small difference

The Peptide Study Looked Convincing Until Researchers Asked What It Actually Proved: How Laboratory Findings Become Misleading Human Health Claims

A laboratory experiment produces an impressive result. Researchers observe a measurable biological response after exposing cells to a synthetic peptide. The findings appear in a scientific paper, attract attention online, and eventually bec

Spotlight on M/Y Serdal, a 26m De Birs yacht for sale in Dubai

Serdal offers potential owners something a mere listing can’t, namely the chance to charter her before making an offer. Try before you buy, if you will, this 26-metre superyacht, built by Egyptian shipyard De Birs and delivered to her origi

The World’s New Pandemic: Antisemitism

The alarming rise of antisemitism around the world tells us something profoundly disturbing: our societies are becoming ill.

Minotaur – From Russia With Love

Minotaur feels like a family drama about infidelity, which it would be if it was set anywhere except Russia where money and power are so bound.

Muge “Emma” Cody: Where AI Is Already Paying Off in Business Development

Ask Muge "Emma" Cody where AI helps business development teams most, and she starts not with technology, but time.

The Used-Car Business That Grows Sales but Runs Short of Cash: How Independent Automotive Founders Can Manage Inventory Transfers, Vehicle Transport and Working Capital...

A used-car business can record more sales, add vehicles to its inventory and attract customers from a wider geographic area while becoming less financially flexible. The problem may not appear in the sales figures. It emerges when money is

Related Articles

Popular Categories