Immigrant Impact on Public Schools – Crisis? or Solution?

Do immigrants put a strain on public resources such as school?

This is one of the complaints people have against permitting so many immigrants, legal or illegal into the U.S. so it is worth looking at the facts, pro and con.

Because there really are good reasons to welcome immigrant students and there are reasons they are straining our resources. It is important to recall the times when there signs in business windows “Irish need not apply.”

The following is a document created entirely by Google’s Gemini Advanced Pro Deep Research and, other than fact checking and some minor formatting changes this has been left intact starting below here. Numbers at the end of some sentences refer to the footnotes at the end of the document.

The Real Impact of Immigrants on Public Schools in the United States

Immigration is a complex and multifaceted phenomenon that has a significant impact on various aspects of society, including public education. The United States, a nation built on immigration, has a long history of absorbing newcomers into its public school system. This article aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the real impact of immigrants on public schools, examining both the positive and negative aspects.

Demographics and Enrollment Trends in Schools

Immigrant students represent a growing segment of the U.S. public school population. In 2021, students from immigrant-headed households (legal and illegal) accounted for nearly one out of four (23 percent) students in public schools. This is double the 11 percent in 1990 and more than triple the 7 percent in 1980 1. Of these students, 83 percent were born in the United States, highlighting the multigenerational impact of immigration on public schools 1.

It is important to note that the impact of immigration on schools tends to be concentrated geographically. A significant proportion of students from immigrant households are clustered in specific areas. In fact, just 700 of the nation’s 2,351 Census Bureau-designated Public Use Microdata Areas (PUMAs) account for two-thirds (seven million) of students from immigrant households. These same PUMAs account for just over one-third of total public school enrollment 1. This concentration has implications for resource allocation and equity in education.

Moreover, the recent influx of immigrants, particularly under the Biden-Harris administration’s open borders policies, has placed a considerable strain on school resources. Reports indicate that between 500,000 and one million children of illegal immigrants have entered the United States, further crowding schools and potentially impacting the quality of education provided to all students 2.

Academic Performance in Modern Schools

There is considerable debate surrounding the academic performance of immigrant students compared to their native-born peers. Research suggests that immigrant students, on average, tend to have lower mean reading, math, and science achievement test scores across 34 Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) nations, including the United States 3. However, it’s crucial to consider the heterogeneity within the immigrant population. Factors such as age at migration, socioeconomic status, and English language proficiency can significantly influence academic outcomes.

Immigrants often face challenges in terms of educational attainment due to legal, administrative, or linguistic barriers. For example, in 2017, twice as many foreign-born youth as natives left school early in the European Union 4. This highlights the need for targeted support and interventions to ensure the educational success of immigrant students.

Studies have shown that first-generation immigrants score consistently lower than native-born students in the United States 5.

For example, on the PISA science test, first-generation immigrants would rank 33rd among the 36 participating OECD countries, while native-born Americans would rank 16th 5. However, second-generation immigrants tend to perform around the same level as native-born students overall 5. This suggests that with adequate support and integration, immigrant students can achieve academic parity with their native-born peers.

Furthermore, research indicates that greater exposure to immigrant peers can be positively correlated with math and reading scores among U.S.-born students 6. This suggests that the presence of immigrant students can have a beneficial effect on the overall academic performance of the classroom.

It is also important to consider the high school dropout rates of recent immigrant youth. As of 2021, 9 percent of recent-immigrant youth ages 14 to 17 were not enrolled in and had not completed high school, compared to 3 percent of longer-residing immigrant and native-born youth 7. Among 18-to-21-year-old youth, the share out of school and without a high school diploma was 15 percent for recent immigrants, 8 percent for longer-residing immigrants, and 5 percent for the native-born 7. These findings underscore the need to provide appropriate support to ensure the success of recent immigrant students in U.S. schools.

In an international comparison, a study in Spain found that immigrant students had lower academic performance than their native counterparts. In Mathematics, students of immigrant origin obtained a mean of 439.1 points compared to 491.7 points obtained by their Spanish counterparts 8. This highlights the challenges faced by immigrant students in different educational contexts.

Impact on School Resources and Funding

The influx of immigrant students has implications for school resources and funding. One major challenge is the increased demand for English language instruction and support services for students with limited English proficiency. The number of certified English-learner instructors has declined in recent years, making it difficult for schools to meet the needs of this growing population 9.

old one room school house generated by Google Gemini Advanced

Furthermore, immigrant students are more likely to come from low-income families, which can strain school budgets and resources. In 2021, 21 percent of public school students from immigrant households lived in poverty, accounting for 29 percent of all students living below the poverty line 1. This concentration of low-income students in certain schools can create challenges in providing adequate resources and support for all students.

The lower income of immigrant households can also create funding challenges for schools. Since tax contributions generally reflect income levels, immigration can cause a significant increase in enrollment without a corresponding increase in tax revenue 1. This can lead to a disparity between the demand for resources and the available funding.

Moreover, the requirement for schools to accommodate the children of illegal immigrants, as mandated by the 1982 Supreme Court ruling Plyler v. Doe, places a significant financial burden on American citizens 10. This is because illegal immigrant families often have low incomes and pay little to no taxes, resulting in the cost of educating their children falling primarily on taxpayers.

The influx of unaccompanied children also poses challenges for school resources. In 2023, 113,495 unaccompanied children were apprehended by immigration authorities and transferred to the custody of the federal Office of Refugee Resettlement 9. These children often require additional support and services, which can strain school resources.

It is important to acknowledge the contributions of undocumented workers to the education system. While they are largely barred from working at public education institutions, they play a significant role in child and day care services, where almost 200,000 undocumented workers are employed 11. This highlights the multifaceted ways in which immigrants contribute to the education sector.

Social and Cultural Impact on Schools

Immigrant students bring a wealth of cultural and linguistic diversity to public schools. This diversity can enrich the learning environment for all students, promoting cross-cultural understanding and global awareness 12. It can expose students to different perspectives, languages, and traditions, fostering a more inclusive and globally-minded school community.

However, this diversity can also create challenges in terms of communication, cultural sensitivity, and addressing potential biases or prejudices. Schools need to be proactive in creating inclusive environments where all students feel welcome and respected, regardless of their background.

One positive aspect is that immigrant students, on average, have fewer serious disciplinary incidents than their U.S.-born peers 13. This can have a beneficial effect on the overall school climate, creating a more positive and productive learning environment for all students.

Furthermore, many immigrant students come to the United States with strong aspirations for academic success and a desire to contribute positively to their new communities 14. This motivation can be an asset to the classroom and the school as a whole.

Challenges and Negative Impacts on Schools

While there are many positive aspects to the presence of immigrant students in public schools, there are also potential challenges and negative impacts.

Social and Emotional Well-being:

• One concern is the potential for increased social tensions and prejudice against immigrant students, particularly in the context of heightened anti-immigrant sentiment.
• Immigration enforcement practices can have a detrimental impact on the academic performance and well-being of immigrant students. Studies have shown that increased immigration enforcement can lead to declines in math test scores, a decreased sense of belonging and safety, and increased bullying among Latinx students 15.
• Immigrant students may experience emotional and behavioral challenges due to fears of deportation and family separation. This can affect their ability to focus on their studies and participate fully in school activities 16.
• The COVID-19 pandemic has exacerbated challenges for immigrant families, including language barriers and technology gaps, potentially hindering their access to educational resources and support 17.

Resource Allocation and Equity:

• Overcrowding in schools with high concentrations of immigrant students can strain resources, increase class sizes, and make it more difficult for teachers to provide individual attention to students.
• The geographical clustering of immigrant families, often in low-income neighborhoods, can place a strain on school resources in those areas 18. This can exacerbate existing inequalities and create challenges in providing equitable access to quality education for all students.

Successful Integration Strategies

Despite the challenges, there are many examples of successful integration of immigrant students into public schools. Schools that embrace diversity, provide adequate language support, and foster a welcoming and inclusive environment tend to have better outcomes for immigrant students 12.

Key Strategies:

• Involving Immigrant Parents: Actively engaging immigrant parents in their children’s education can be highly beneficial. Initiatives that empower immigrant parents and provide them with the tools to support their children’s learning have shown positive results 12.
• Culturally Responsive Teaching: Implementing culturally responsive teaching practices that acknowledge and value the diverse backgrounds of immigrant students can create a more inclusive and supportive learning environment.
• Language Support: Providing adequate language support, such as English as a Second Language (ESL) programs and bilingual education, is crucial for helping immigrant students acquire the language skills necessary for academic success.
• Community Partnerships: Collaborating with community-based organizations that serve immigrant families can provide valuable resources and support for students and their families.

It is important to recognize that successful integration requires compassion, commitment, and adequate funding 19. School administrators, policymakers, and community members must work together to create a welcoming and supportive environment where immigrant students can thrive.

Conclusion, Impact of Immigrants on Schools

The impact of immigrants on public schools is complex and multifaceted. While there are challenges associated with integrating a growing population of students with diverse needs, there are also significant benefits in terms of cultural enrichment and academic potential.

By embracing diversity, providing adequate resources and support, and fostering inclusive learning environments, public schools can harness the positive contributions of immigrant students and ensure their success.

Moreover, immigrant-origin students are increasingly filling critical career and skills needs in the U.S., particularly in healthcare and STEM fields 20. Educating immigrant students effectively is not only a matter of social equity but also an investment in the future workforce and economic prosperity of the nation.

Synthesis of Findings

This analysis reveals a complex interplay of factors influencing the impact of immigrants on U.S. public schools. While demographic trends indicate a significant rise in immigrant student enrollment, their academic performance is varied, influenced by factors like generational status and socioeconomic background. Notably, second-generation immigrants tend to achieve academic parity with native-born peers.

The financial implications are significant, with increased demands for language support and resources potentially straining school budgets, particularly in low-income districts with high immigrant concentrations. However, the cultural and social benefits of diversity are undeniable, enriching the learning environment for all students.

Challenges remain, including potential social tensions, overcrowding, and the need for specialized support services. Successful integration hinges on inclusive policies, adequate funding, and community engagement.

Ultimately, fostering a welcoming and supportive environment is crucial for maximizing the positive contributions of immigrant students and ensuring their academic success while enriching the educational experience for all.

Recommendations:

• Policymakers:

• Increase funding for schools with high immigrant student populations to ensure adequate resources for language support, specialized services, and smaller class sizes.
• Implement policies that support the social and emotional well-being of immigrant students, such as access to mental health services and protection against bullying and discrimination.
• Invest in teacher training programs that focus on culturally responsive teaching and working with English language learners.

• Educators:

• Create inclusive classroom environments that value diversity and promote cross-cultural understanding.
• Provide individualized support for immigrant students, taking into account their unique needs and challenges.
• Communicate effectively with immigrant parents and involve them in their children’s education.

• Community Members:

• Support schools in their efforts to integrate immigrant students by volunteering, donating resources, and advocating for inclusive policies.
• Engage in dialogue and activities that promote understanding and acceptance of immigrants in the community.

Works cited – footnotes

1. Mapping the Impact of Immigration on Public Schools, accessed December 25, 2024, https://cis.org/Report/Mapping-Impact-Immigration-Public-Schools
2. ‘Overwhelmed’: Hundreds of Thousands of Migrants in U.S. Public Schools Is ‘a Crisis in the Making’ – The Washington Stand, accessed December 25, 2024, https://washingtonstand.com/commentary/overwhelmed-hundreds-of-thousands-of-migrants-in-us-public-schools-is-a-crisis-in-the-making
3. The Impact of National and School Contextual Factors on the Academic Performance of Immigrant Students – Frontiers, accessed December 25, 2024, https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/education/articles/10.3389/feduc.2021.793790/full
4. International migration | 2019 GEM Report, accessed December 25, 2024, https://gem-report-2019.unesco.org/chapter/introduction/international-migration/
5. U.S. Immigrant Performance on International Tests, accessed December 25, 2024, https://cis.org/Report/US-Immigrant-Performance-International-Tests
6. Denying Education to Immigrant Children is Morally Wrong – and Practically Dumb – The 74, accessed December 25, 2024, https://www.the74million.org/article/denying-education-to-immigrant-children-is-morally-wrong-and-practically-dumb/
7. www.migrationpolicy.org, accessed December 25, 2024, https://www.migrationpolicy.org/sites/default/files/publications/mpi-recent-immigrant-children-2023_final.pdf
8. Academic Performance of Native and Immigrant Students: A Study …, accessed December 25, 2024, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5062750/
9. A More Complete Picture of Immigration’s Impact on U.S. Public …, accessed December 25, 2024, https://www.edweek.org/policy-politics/a-more-complete-picture-of-immigrations-impact-on-u-s-public-schools/2024/06
10. The Elephant in the Classroom: Mass Immigration Imposing Colossal Cost and Challenges on Public Education | FAIRUS.org, accessed December 25, 2024, https://www.fairus.org/issue/elephant-classroom-mass-immigration-imposing-colossal-cost-and-challenges-public-education
11. Immigrants and the U.S. Educational System – New American Economy Research Fund, accessed December 25, 2024, https://research.newamericaneconomy.org/report/immigrants-america-educational-system/
12. Promoting School Success for Immigrant-Origin Students – EdResearch for Action, accessed December 25, 2024, https://edresearchforaction.org/research-briefs/promoting-school-success-for-immigrant-origin-students/
13. Do Immigrant Students Help the Academic Outcomes of U.S.-Born Peers? One Study Says Yes, accessed December 25, 2024, https://www.edweek.org/teaching-learning/do-immigrant-students-help-the-academic-outcomes-of-u-s-born-peers-one-study-says-yes/2024/01
14. Testimony: Immigrant Students Make Our Schools and Our Country Stronger, accessed December 25, 2024, https://tcf.org/content/commentary/testimony-immigrant-students-make-our-schools-and-our-country-stronger/
15. THE IMPACT OF A ON U.S. STUDENTS AND SCHOOLS – UCLA Civil Rights Project, accessed December 25, 2024, https://civilrightsproject.ucla.edu/research/k-12-education/immigration-immigrant-students/the-impact-of-a-broken-immigration-system-on-u.s.-students-and-schools/UCLA_ImmigrationEnforcementBrief_12-4-23-v3.pdf
16. Immigration and Its Impact on American Schools, accessed December 25, 2024, https://aacte.org/2019/09/immigration-and-its-impact-on-american-schools/
17. Challenges for Immigrant Children in the U.S. Education System – Giving Compass, accessed December 25, 2024, https://givingcompass.org/article/challenges-for-immigrant-children-in-the-u-s-education-system
18. For Children, the Immigrant Experience Begins in School | George …, accessed December 25, 2024, https://www.bushcenter.org/catalyst/immigration/wicks-schools-and-immigrants
19. Case Studies: Welcoming Immigrant & Refugee Students, & How Washington Can Help, accessed December 25, 2024, https://www.the74million.org/article/case-studies-welcoming-immigrant-refugee-students-how-washington-can-help/

20. National Data on Immigrant Students, accessed December 25, 2024, https://www.higheredimmigrationportal.org/national/national-data/

Study: Cellphones in Classroom Can Lower Students’ Grades