A Stake in the Heart of 25,000 Small California Businesses

A stake was hammered into the heart of New York Affiliate Marketers, and now California Affiliate Marketers are in the crosshairs. The goal, a small and possibly phantom amount of state sales tax income.

In California, up to 25,000 small businesses are directly at risk. Some of these small businesses employ many people and some are still growing and employing additional staff, even in this down economy.

“The state will not get the money they think they will, because vendors will just dump their affiliates. … small businesses will be harmed in the process.”

New York Affiliates

If you are a New York Affiliate,
what is happening to your business?
comment@newsblaze.com

Earlier proposed legislation in AB178 was shelved in April. Now the State is getting desperate for money and clutching at straws, this legislation is being resurrected and may be squeezed into another bill.

The estimated additional income to the state is not likely to materialize. Worse than that, it could turn into a net loss for the state. The harm to tens of thousands of small California businesses, and a several large ones, could be irreparable. Collateral damage to other California businesses that support the directly affected businesses is also likely.

At issue is the fact that the legislation would unbalance the playing field, handing California’s advantage over to other states and locking California businesses out of the running.

Affiliate Marketing, also called Performance Marketing has been a real boon to vendors large and small. It allows them to sell their products across the USA and around the world, even if they are based in a small town in the middle of nowhere.

How it Works

An out of State merchant creates a banner ad with a tracking code. Internet publishers (like NewsBlaze or savings.com, ebates.com) place the ad with its tracking code on their website. A website visitor clicks on the ad and is sent to the merchant’s website. Once there, they may or may not buy something. If they do, the merchant knows which site sent the visitor and compensates them at a pre-defined rate. The publisher doesn’t know who the visitor was or even if a sale was made by the merchant, until much later, when they check stats at the merchant tracking site. The publisher has no part in the sale.

The legislation says this loose relationship constitutes the presence of the merchant in California, the state of the publisher, which it obviously is not. If it became law, the merchant would have to collect California sales tax on the sale. The merchant has options. They can modify their system software, manage the myriad of California sales tax rates and pay California; or they can easily terminate their relationship with this now irritating California publisher. If they terminate the relationship, the publisher makes no income and the state collects no tax.

Many small businesses rely on their relationships with vendors or with middlemen such as Linkshare, Commission Junction, Google and the new CPAPark. The middlemen form relationships with multiple vendors and multiple small businesses, who are publishers of information. Commission Junction has a simplified way for merchants to find relevant publishers and helps publishers find relevant merchants.

The middlemen act as a very important “gateway” between the publishers and the vendors, allowing the publishers to advertise products from vendors they would not be able to work with otherwise. Vendors gain by not needing to find and vet an army of small publishers who would run their ads.

After operating for many years, affiliate maketing has created many jobs. A lot of innovation and many side industries have sprung up around it. These small business are not organized as a group and they generally don’t have a lot of money to throw around on lobbying, they just get on with the job of surviving, growing and employing.

A good sized chunk of that business could soon come to a screeching halt. First, the small California businesses would lose their affiliate income, as the vendors cut them off for the sole reason that they are based in California. The vendor business would go to competitors based in other states that don’t have this legislation. The vendors would lose business for a while, because the other businesses wouldn’t be able to pick up the slack immediately. Some California businesses will only lose a small percentage of their income, while others are 100% exposed.

California businesses all circulate their money in California. Money circulates in mortgages, rent and office leases. Most of us buy business cards and stationery, printer supplies, PCs, packaging. We eat in local restaurants, use local accountants, local temp services and otherwise buy locally. We advertise locally in newspapers, on websites and at Google, another California company. Several small businesses in this group employ 20 or more staff and lease office space.

The next wave of losses will hit businesses that provide advertising services for any of these businesses. Many websites that use google AdSense for income will suffer a loss because many of these California businesses use AdWords to advertise, looking for new members or buyers. If they can’t make money, their advertising will stop. Businesses in other states could pick up the slack, but with thousands of advertisers stopping campaigns, the effect on other publishers would be at the least, disruptive.

Some small businesses may disappear altogether, so cities will lose their business license fees. Banks will lose the cashflow these businesses generate and CPAs, lawyers and temp staff that support them will suffer too.

All of this doom and gloom would sound alarmist and fictional, if it wasn’t for the fact there is recent precedent. New York already implemented similar legislation. By the end of the first week after being enacted, many vendors had dropped all New York-based affiliates. One company, Overstock, reported dropping 3400 small New York businesses – not all were active.

To illustrate some of the collateral damage that could be caused, a coupon company, although not an affiliate, was dropped by Overstock because the fact they created coupons in New York might have been used as a legal argument that the relationship established nexus.

“The state will not get the money they think they will, because vendors will just dump their affiliates. No affiliates, no nexus. Not only will the money not come in, but a lot of small businesses will be harmed in the process.” So says Master Internet Marketer, Declan Dunn.

California may be desperate, but going after a small amount of state sales tax, at the risk of destroying 25,000 small businesses, part of the engine that keeps us afloat, seems like a way to dig the hole much deeper.

Affiliate Marketers based in California should do two things on Monday morning. First, review the Performance Marketing Alliance website. Second, call your state legislator’s office and let them know what effect this legislation would have on your business. You can also send a letter to the editor of NewsBlaze.com – look for the address below this story.

Editor’s Notes:

The 25,000 number comes from the number of affiliates reported by the top middlemen businesses.

NewBlaze has reestimated the number of affiliates, originally tabulated two months ago, based on numbers reported by Linkshare. We have changed the numbers in this story, based on more recent information and will continue to investigate. We apologize for any errors made.

Hot this week

Did David Wineland and Serge Haroche Steal Idea For The Nobel Physics Prize?

Dr. Omerbashich says the Royal Swedish Academy is a Crime Scene and he has the proof that Nobel laureates stole his discovery.

New Approaches to Disaster Relief Challenges

Disaster relief has always been a challenge. NASA, Google,...

3 Legitimate Money Making Methods to Supplement Your Income

In a perfect world, when your landlord raises your...

2016 Predictions by World Renowned Medium and Psychic Lindy Baker

World renowned medium and psychic Lindy Baker is interviewed by The Hollywood Sentinel, discussing psychic power, the spirit world, life after death, areas of concern in 2016, and much more.

Digital Coupon Customers Spending More Than Double At Stores

A new study shows that customers who use digital coupons go shopping more for groceries and other household goods more often and spend more on their shopping trips.

Legendary Peace Tour: Top African Former Professionals to Arrive in Somalia

Somalia prepares to welcome three of Africa’s most senior football legends; Jay-Jay Okocha, {Nigeria} Emmanuel Adebayor {Togo} and Samuel Eto'e {Cameroon}

Myocarditis Risk From mRNA Vaccines Called “Well Documented” in Major New Review

A major new review urges withdrawal of mRNA COVID vaccines, citing high myocarditis risk in young men and calling for urgent action.

The Calculated Extermination Of Jews In Auschwitz Death Camp

A reminder to the Jews: never forget what was visited upon you in WW2. Every Jewish generation - present and future – must fully understand what was done to the Jewish people during the 20th century.

Smoke, Screens & Sacrifice: The War That Was Never Ours

War as two nuclear-armed nations trade missiles, media headlines, and miseries. India claims bold precision strikes, Pakistan claims shooting down jets.

Ambassadorial Change Of The Guard

George Deek concludes his four-year ambassadorial tenure in Azerbaijan as Mr. Ronen Kraus looks forward to e a life changing experience.

Can U.S. Congress Legally Stop Pres. Trump’s Executive Order to Lower High-Cost Drugs? Will Tariffs Kick in?

Millions of Americans can barely afford to buy high-cost drugs on prescription. Low-income citizens have bitterly complained for many years that life-saving drugs that stabilize their health are too darn high.

WHO Finalises Pandemic Treaty Draft as Australia Prepares to Vote

WHO finalises Pandemic Treaty draft as Australia prepares to vote. Critics warn of a power grab and urge rejection over sovereignty fears.

Winner of 2014 District Level Football Tourney Is Now Somalia’s Minister for Youth and Sports

Somalia has a youthful Minister for Youth and Sports, Mohamed Abdulkadir Ali, the man who won district level football tournament in 2014 with his Hamarweyne district team

Related Articles

Popular Categories