NewsBlaze search box Daily News header

Brothers Movie Review

By     get stories by email

Movies about the traumas of US wars seem to fare better when sticking to the more familiar turf of what is going down dramatically on the home front, rather than in conflict abroad. And Brothers, like the fractured psyche of its combat soldier protagonist played by Tobey Maguire, gets it more than right while penetrating the tragic fallout from post-traumatic stress disorder, but shatters and loses its way while conceptualizing contrived war zones far away.

Adapted from Danish filmmaker Susanne Bier's 2004 Brødre and helmed by Irish director Jim Sheridan (My Left Foot), Brothers stars Tobey Maguire as Sam Cahill, a decorated marine. Sam obediently followed in the footsteps of his stern marine vet father, Hank (Sam Shepard), while his younger brother Tommy (Jake Gyllenhaal) has embraced more rebellious tendencies. Tommy, who despises war, has just been released from prison where he spent time for an attempted bank robbery.

Brothers Movie

When the family gathers for a tense farewell dinner where Sam's devoted wife Grace (Natalie Portman)and two small daughters Isabelle (Bailee Madison) and Maggie (Taylor Geare) prepare for his departure for Afghanistan, Tommy is invited to join them as an unwelcome guest. The gathering quickly escalates from awkward to confrontational, as Hank makes little effort to conceal his contempt for a wayward son returning home, and his favored child heading off into harm's way.

When Sam's plane is later shot down in Afghanistan and Grace receives news that he's dead, Tommy is filled with rage towards his family for encouraging Sam to join the military in the first place. But protective feelings towards his brother's brokenhearted widow and her children soon evolve, and eventually blossom into a barely suppressed attraction between Tommy and Grace that is increasingly difficult to resist. And when Sam is eventually found alive and freed from captivity and torture by the Taliban, he returns him to a situation fraught with looming psychological turmoil.

Scenes between Maguire and Gyllenhaal emotionally detonate with a rare passion and intensity on screen. But which unfortunately render the scenes of military conflict artificial and unconvincing in comparison. It's as if Irish director Jim Sheridan may have been more subjectively focused on personal trauma of his own related to the history of terrorism back in his homeland than a determined scrutiny of the Afghan resistance, which plays out as exaggerated caricatures with no basis in logic or reality connected to current events.

The result is a compassionate crafting of lost and found families in wartime, but a seemingly self-censored scenario with the US military establishment and its combat rationale as the troubling invisible elephant in the room. This, while foot soldiers and insurgents alike are set up as the fall guys for precipitating the horrors of war and its psychological scars, not the institutions destroying human beings in the first place, by cultivating in men the concerted impulse to legally engage in murder.

Lionsgate
Rated R
2 stars

Prairie Miller is a multimedia journalist online, in print and on radio. Contact her through NewsBlaze.

  Please click this get stories by email button to be notified about future stories, and please leave a comment below.

  Please leave a comment here     If it does not display within 10 seconds, please refresh the page

Related Movie Reviews News

A gulf in the attitudes of two men had a profound effect on the orphans' fortunes. One is stable and successful and the other had many scrapes with the law.
Thai (arrow), a film by Henry Kro, 37th out of 1190 films from 86 countries. Features 16 year old Karbi heroine Rengsajir P Killingpi, daughter of acclaimed Diphu martial artist
Prairie Miller discusses the beat poets, punk rock, Elijah's journey from Frodo to hero worship, Auden, Blake, McCarthyism, and the radicalization of Thomas
Lucy McBath reminisces about Jordan while discussing 3 1/2 Minutes, Ten Bullets, a documentary chronicling the trial of her son's killer.
A young victimized actor phones in from LA, to speak about An Open Secret, a documentary that exposes the child casting couch rampant in Hollywood
A desk-bound CIA analyst acts as the ears and eyes of Bradley Fine, a veteran spy. Used to seeing action through hidden cameras and listening devices, when the spy is killed, she takes over his job.

 

NewsBlaze Writers Of The Month


Popular Stories This Month

newsletter logo

NewsBlaze
Copyright © 2004-2014 NewsBlaze Pty. Ltd.
Use of this website is subject to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy  | DMCA Notice               Press Room   |    Visit NewsBlaze Mobile Site