Azerbaijan-Armenia: A Baseless, Senseless Conflict

Azerbaijan Journal – October 2017

Day One

Several months ago, I had the honor to be invited to Azerbaijan to witness the ongoing development of a former USSR satellite, now working on its 25-year-old independence. I was impressed by what I saw but, in all fairness, knew that I did not complete my reportage.

On my first visit I encountered much formality and saw what my guests wanted me to see. This time, I am here to report what I want to see and tell about the daily life of the Azerbaijani people. I report what is taking place in a country that is building its international recognition.

So here I am again in Azerbaijan to tell, in all fairness and honesty, what I see, sense, smell and think.

Summary of the Conflict

The Azerbaijan-Armenia is called ‘The Nagorno-Karabakh War,’ is referred to by Armenians as the ‘Artsakh Liberation War.’ This was an ethnic and territorial conflict that took place in the late 1980s to May 1994, in the Nagorno-Karabakh enclave, in southwestern Azerbaijan, between the majority ethnic Armenians of Nagorno-Karabakh backed by the Republic of Armenia and Russia, and the Republic of Azerbaijan.

The entire base of the conflict could be summed up as ethnic groups and their ability to coexist, much influenced by Armenia’s claim to territory whose integrity is clearly with Azerbaijan.

Full-scale fighting erupted in the late winter of 1992. In the spring of 1993, Armenian forces captured regions outside the enclave itself, threatening the involvement of other countries in the region. By the end of the war in 1994, the Armenians were in full control of the enclave, with the exception of the Shahumyan Region, in addition to surrounding areas of Azerbaijan proper, most notably the Lachin Corridor, a mountain pass that links Nagorno-Karabakh with mainland Armenia.

A Russian-brokered ceasefire was signed in May 1994, but regular peace talks between Armenia and Azerbaijan mediated by the OSCE Minsk Group (The Minsk Group is headed by a co-chairmanship of France, Russia and the United States. The Minsk Group also includes the following participating states: Belarus, Germany, Italy, Portugal, the Netherlands, Sweden, Finland, Turkey as well as Armenia and Azerbaijan) have failed to result in a peace treaty.

This has left the Nagorno-Karabakh area in a state of legal limbo, with a synthetic Nagorno-Karabakh Republic, established and controlled by Armenia in illegally occupied regions of Azerbaijan, remaining de facto independent but internationally unrecognized. Armenian forces currently occupy approximately 20% of Azerbaijan’s rightful territory in and around the Nagorno-Karabakh area.

As a result of the conflict, as many as 230,000 Armenians from Azerbaijan and 800,000 Azerbaijanis from Armenia and Karabakh have been displaced.

Sore point

The invasion of Armenia was one sided. At that time, Azerbaijan was adjusting to its brand-new independence and its military was in its nascent stages. The military was not fully ready for its job to protect Azerbaijani land. The result was that they ended losing a hefty chunk of Azerbaijan’s contiguous integral territorial land.

That is a sore point for people who love their land, their history in the land and more so, land they should not have lost. They want it back and not necessarily under their terms, willing to negotiate and make concessions so long as they can return to their homeland.

But Armenia has developed a belligerent and deaf attitude to any rational negotiations. At the armistice frontier line of contact bullets are shot by the Armenian forces daily and skirmishes are ubiquitous.

A Country in the Clutches of a Quarrelsome Neighbor

Azerbaijan, a majority Moslem country, is a peace-loving country that accommodates, in a remarkable coexistence, many ethnic and religion groups. As a Jewess who is constantly witnessing the toll of hate that Moslems show toward the Jewish state of Israel and general intolerance by Moslem societies, I am taken aback by such coexistence accomplished in a Moslem-ruled country.

On the contrary, Armenia is seeking to prolong the conflict and constantly agitates its neighbor in an attempt to escalate the fighting. For instance, in 2016 a ‘standard’ skirmish, started by the Armenians, took two days to end. 21 Azerbaijani soldiers lost their lives but Azerbaijan managed to take back a strategic hill and secured the safe return of Internally Displaced People (IDP) to their destroyed village, Çocuq Mərcanlı.

village memorial to the 21 fallen.
Çocuq Mərcanlı village memorial to the 21 fallen
Çocuq Mərcanlı village with military personnel, former president Heydar Aliyev pix in background,
Çocuq Mərcanlı village with military personnel, former president Heydar Aliyev pix in background

Çocuq Mərcanlı

Çocuq Mərcanlı is a village in the Jabrayil District of Azerbaijan. In 1993, in the course of the Nagorno-Karabakh War, the Armenian army pushed Azerbaijani forces out of the village after gaining control of the nearby hills. The village remained under Armenian control for four months, during which it was completely razed. Having failed to maintain control of the village, the Armenians retreated to the nearby hills.

Çocuq Mərcanlı turned into no man’s land and its population never returned out of fear of shelling, with the exception of one family who remained on the land, no matter what.

Çocuq Mərcanlı new village
Çocuq Mərcanlı new village
Çocuq Mərcanlı village Iran's mountains' border from the village Mosque.
Çocuq Mərcanlı village Iran’s mountains’ border from the village Mosque

During the 2016 Armenian-Azerbaijani clashes, Azerbaijani troops regained control over the strategic Lalatapa hill, located 2.9 kilometers (1.8 mi) north-west of the village. That shifted Çocuq Mərcanlı away from the immediate front line and allowed safe access to the village.

On 7 April 2016, internally displaced persons from Çocuq Mərcanlı visited their home village for the first time in 23 years. In January 2017, Azerbaijan decided to invest 2 million euros into rebuilding the village, with an initial plan of paving a road and construction of 50 houses, school, medical clinic and other required amenities. At present, 100 more housing units are being built to receive 100 more families.

Çocuq Mərcanlı, aslo Chojuk-Marjanly is currently the only village of the Jabrayil District effectively controlled by the Azerbaijani army.

My visit to Çocuq Mərcanlı, accompanied by Azerbaijani military personal, where I met with the first IDP who returned to their ancestral village was impressive.

For starters, the people have a roof over their head, running water, food and much hope. That is a very good start.

The surrounding agricultural land is full of landmines the Armenians systematically put in the ground. Now the Azerbaijanis are busy doing the tedious and dangerous cleaning up of the land. They remove the hidden bombs so the once-fertile agricultural land can go back to its best use, producing food.

Çocuq Mərcanlı village school - more kids will join classes
Çocuq Mərcanlı village school – more kids will join classes
Çocuq Mərcanlı village officials with president Ilham Aliyev poster who gifted them the school.
Çocuq Mərcanlı village officials with president Ilham Aliyev poster who gifted them the school

From the village, I was escorted to the nearby army encampment surrounded by guards and protective soil hills, at 1-kilometer distance from the Iranian border and 500 meters from the frontier with Armenia. I was told that if I tried getting closer to the front line I might be shot at. That is how trigger-happy the Armenians are.

Çocuq Mərcanlı village military post troops who received us.
Çocuq Mərcanlı village military post troops who received us

My Forthright Questions to the Military Personnel, Their ViewPoint

Speaking with the military personnel who accompanied me, I threw at them forthright questions such as, “what is the solution? How to bring about an end to such unfortunate and senseless tension and ongoing armed skirmishes?”

I could sense the anger. Why? Because the Azerbaijani military is now strong and ready, what it was not in 1993. They are angry that they could not protect the people before, as they can now.

There are four United Nations Security Council (UNSC) resolutions demanding Armenia withdraw its troops from Azerbaijan territory. Well, the first rule is do not rely on the UN. The United Nations organization is good at speaking, it is a total failure to carrying out its job. It will not solve your problem you will have to do it on your own. The UN cannot solve this conflict and since Azerbaijanis are eager to solve it, resolution is in their hands.

Near Çocuq Mərcanlı village with my military personnel escort.
Near the Çocuq Mərcanlı village with my military personnel escort

Though the Minsk Group recognize the integrity of Azerbaijan to its land occupied by Armenia, this powerful group has not embarked on putting sufficient pressure on Armenia to abide by the UNSC binding resolution and withdraw its troops. That is what the Azerbaijanis would love to see. Pressure Armenia enough so it withdraws.

Azerbaijan, a peace-loving country, would like to sit at the negotiations table with Armenia and arrive at a solution that will serve the displaced people of both nations and serve the two countries as a whole. Armenia is not interested in logic, rather in confrontation.

However, if all fails, I am told that only war will resolve this conflict, a war that will return every piece of land that belongs to Azerbaijan to it rightful owner and then there will be peaceful progress.

In the south-west part of Azerbaijan, there are glimpses of hope. I saw a shining ray of hope in the faces of the district manager, the village mayoral supervisor, the school headmaster and the military. They are starting life again where, to them and their ancestors is their homeland.

I personally strongly suggest a strong and invincible Azerbaijan that has all the necessary deterrence tools to push back its enemy, Armenia. I pray for a peaceful end of a baseless, senseless conflict, soonest.

Cocuq Mercanli old village ruination by Armenia.
Cocuq Mercanli old village ruined by Armenia.
Nurit Greenger

During the 2006 second Lebanon War, Nurit Greenger, referenced then as the “Accidental Reporter” felt compelled to become an activist. Being an ‘out-of-the-box thinker, Nurit is a passionately committed advocate for Jews, Israel, the United States, and the Free World in general. From Southern California, Nurit serves as a “one-woman Hasbarah army” for Israel who believes that if you stand for nothing, you will fall for anything.

Email Notification

Get notification of new stories by Nurit Greenger, in your Email.